The Food is Top Quality.....and so Delicious. If you haven't been there I Suggest you try it, would such a Warm Friendly Atmosphere. Once you try it, you will absolutely come back again!!! M m m m m m m m m!!!!!

We've been coming here for dinner a lot lately and love their food. Rich and delicious steak, burgers and amazing french fries and onion rings. We were very impressed with the gentleman that was our server.

Amazing service, Meagan was awesome!! Service and food highly recommend!! Kids loved the sampler platter, burger and wings were amazing too!

Love coming to this establishment. Bartender Joann is very attentive and makes delicious cocktails. The food is always delicious and top notch. Jimmy, the owner, is very friendly and welcoming.

Atmosphere Old City Public House offers a warm and inviting atmosphere that combines a traditional pub vibe with a contemporary twist. The interior features rustic wooden accents, comfortable seating, and a cozy bar area, making it a great spot for both casual meet-ups with friends and family gatherings. The ambiance is relaxed, often highlighted by friendly chatter and the sounds of sports games, especially during the season. Food and Drink The menu at Old City Public House is diverse, featuring a variety of American pub fare with some unique twists. You can expect classic options like burgers, wings, and fries, alongside more innovative dishes that showcase local ingredients. Many patrons rave about the quality of the food, emphasizing the generous portions and flavorful preparations. In terms of drinks, the pub offers a wide selection of craft beers, wines, and cocktails. The beer list often includes local brews, which is a nice touch for those looking to try something regional. Happy hour specials and themed nights can be a fun way to explore their drink offerings at a more affordable price. Service The service at Old City Public House is generally praised for being attentive and friendly. The staff is knowledgeable about the menu and is often willing to make recommendations based on your preferences. Whether you’re dining in or just stopping by for a drink, you can expect a welcoming experience. Entertainment Old City Public House frequently hosts live music and events, adding to its charm as a community gathering spot. Trivia nights and other themed events are popular among locals, creating a lively atmosphere that encourages participation and camaraderie. Community Engagement The establishment is known for being involved in the local community, hosting fundraisers and events that support various causes. This commitment to community engagement helps foster a loyal customer base and adds to the overall appeal of the pub. Conclusion Overall, Old City Public House in Lake Ronkonkoma is a great spot for anyone looking to enjoy good food, a wide selection of drinks, and a friendly atmosphere. Whether you’re stopping in for a casual bite or planning a night out with friends, it’s a place that caters to a wide range of tastes and preferences. If you’ve been there before, what was your favorite dish or experience? If you’re planning to go, what are you most excited about?

Food is excellent t. Very friendly staff. The dinner specials make it very affordable. We sometimes eat there twice a week

Amazing staff, food and drinks! Meagan & Joanne are the best bartenders and people overall. The owner Jimmy is always such a pleasure to talk to and the chef is the nicest guy! Love this place all around! Again, food is amazing!!

Great meal, the service was attentive, owner or manager (not sure) was welcoming. We will be regulars!