Old City Public House Menu (2025 Update)

Welcome to Old City Public House, a vibrant gem located in Lake Ronkonkoma that combines a warm ambiance with a menu filled with mouthwatering options. Renowned as the "Home of the French Dip," this establishment delights its patrons with classic pub fare enhanced by unique twists.

  • Signature Dishes: Don't miss the Buffalo Chicken Wrap or the indulgent Chicken Finger Melt, both offering hearty flavors that keep guests coming back.
  • Wings: Their classic and boneless wings are a crowd favorite, perfectly paired with extra Blue cheese dressing.
  • Atmosphere: The rustic charm and lively sports vibe create an inviting space for gatherings, whether casual or celebratory.
  • Community Spirit: Old City Public House is a pillar in the community, frequently hosting events that engage and entertain locals.

With attentive service and a focus on quality, this pub promises a delightful dining experience that will keep your taste buds entertained!

Home of the French Dip! - Appetizers

Chicken Quesadilla

Savory chicken, a blend of cheeses and bacon served with sour cream and salsa.

US$16.00

Mexican Pizza

12” flour tortilla fried until golden brown topped with seasoned beef, mixed cheese, diced tomatoes, black olives and jalapenos served with sour cream and salsa.

US$18.00

Beer-Battered Onion Rings

A generous portion of golden-fried onions served with horseradish dressing dipping sauce

US$13.00

Buffalo Shrimp (5 Pcs}

Served with blue cheese dressing.

US$16.00

Mozzarella Cheese Sticks

Five Mozzarella sticks served with marinara sauce.

US$12.00

Potato Skins

Smothered in melted cheeses and bacon, served with sour cream.

US$12.00

Old City Mud Fries

Fries topped with melted Mozzarella cheese served with brown gravy on the side for dipping.

US$12.00

Beef Nachos

Seasoned beef, melted cheese, topped with shredded lettuce, tomatoes, and black olives served with salsa and sour cream.

US$17.00

The Big Pretzel

Served with Cheese Sauce and Mustard

US$13.00

Fried Zucchini Sticks

lightly breaded and fried Zucchini Sticks served with marinara

US$12.00

Buffalo Chicken Nachos

Chopped buffalo chicken fingers, melted cheeses topped with shredded lettuce and chopped tomatoes, served with blue cheese dressing, sour cream and salsa.

US$17.00

OCPH Sampler Platter

A sampler of chicken wings, Cheese Sticks. and onion Rings

US$24.00

House Sampler

Chicken wings, Onion Rings, Cheese Sticks and potato skins served with all the sauces. No substitutions

US$22.00

20 Classic Chicken Wings

20 Bone in chicken wings served with blue cheese and celery. Please note: if you require extra Blue cheese dressing please use the Extra Blue cheese key for additional 3.00 charge

US$30.00

50 Classic Chicken Wings

50 Bone in Chicken wings served with Blue cheese and celery. Please note this item takes 20 to 30 minutes. In addition if you want extra dressing you must charge using the extra dressing key 3.00

US$70.00

Ribs Wings And Onion Rings

Sampling of our Baby Back Ribs, Wings and onion Rings served with Fries

US$22.00

Creamy Cheesecake

Delicious creamy cheesecake.

US$8.00

Home of the French Dip! - Dessert

Home of the French Dip! - Signature Premium French Dip Sandwiches

Extra Au Jus Gravy Or Brown Gravy ( Please Specify)

US$2.00

Brooklyn French Dip

toasted garlic roll with melted american, mozzarella and roasted red peppers, served with 2 onion rings

US$21.00

French Dip Sandwich With American Cheese & Fried Onions

Featuring our slow-roasted beef served on our special bakery roll served with a side of au jus fries and pickle.

US$21.00

French Dip Sandwich With Mushrooms & Mozzarella Cheese

Featuring our slow-roasted beef served on our special bakery roll served with a side of au jus fries and pickle.

US$21.00

Roasted Turkey French Dip Sandwich

Served with Swiss cheese and roasted red peppers.

US$21.00

French Dip Sandwich With American Cheese

Featuring our slow-roasted beef served on our special bakery roll served with a side of au jus fries and pickle.

US$21.00

French Dip Sandwich With Swiss Cheese & Sauteed Onions

Featuring our slow-roasted beef served on our special bakery roll served with a side of au jus fries and pickle.

US$21.00

French Dip Sandwich With Mushrooms, Peppers, & Onions

Toasted Hero Roll Boars head Roast beef topped with mushrooms, peppers , onions and American cheese served with our signature au jus and trench fries

US$21.00

Native NY French Dip

Roast beef topped with American Cheese, Sauteed Green peppers, sauteed mushrooms and sauteed onions served on a hero roll and fries

US$21.00

Pastrami French Dip

Pastrami on Toasted Garlic Hero roll with melted swiss and served with spicy mustard and Au jus

US$21.00

Loaded French Dip

Boars head roast beef on a toasted garlic hero roll, topped with mozzarella cheese,, sauteed onions and double bacon

US$21.00

French Onion Soup

Caramelized onions in a savory broth topped with melted cheese and a golden-brown crust.

US$8.00

Home of the French Dip! - Soup

Home of the French Dip! - Wings

Classic Wings (20 Pcs)

We have added an extra Blue cheese Dressing button, please use this when requesting extra dressing, BBQ, hot or House sauce

US$29.00

Classic Wings (10 Pcs)

We have added a button for extra Blue Cheese dressing, please use this when requesting extra blue cheese, hot sauce, BBQ or House sauce

US$18.00

Boneless Wings (10 Pcs)

We have added extra Blue cheese button, when requesting extra Blue cheese Dressing, hot, house or BBQ sauce

US$14.00

Extra Blue Cheese Dressing

Soup cup of our Blue cheese dressing

US$4.00

Boneless Wings (20 Pcs)

We have added a button for extra Blue cheese dressing, BBQ, hot or House sauce. please use this when requesting Extra Dressing or Sauces

US$20.00

Create Your Own Burger

Create your toppings, choose your cheese, served with 2 onion rings and fries.

US$21.00

Hamburger*

Menu items can be cooked to order. *Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

US$17.00

Patty Melt*

Beef patty, fried onions, and Swiss cheese on grilled rye. Menu items can be cooked to order. *Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

US$19.00

Cheeseburger*

Choice of American, Swiss or Mozzarella. Menu items can be cooked to order. *Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

US$18.00

Mushroom & Mozzarella Cheese Burger*

Menu items can be cooked to order. *Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

US$19.00

Signature Burger

Signature Burger topped with Cheddar cheese, sauteed Mushrooms and 2 onion rings served on a toasted garlic roll comes with fries and a pickle

US$20.00

Swiss & Sauteed Onion Burger*

Menu items can be cooked to order. *Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

US$19.00

American Cheese & Bacon Burger*

Menu items can be cooked to order. *Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

US$19.00

BBQ, American Cheese, & Bacon Burger*

Menu items can be cooked to order. *Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

US$19.00

Brooklyn Burger*

Slice of American, Slice of Mozzarella, Bacon and Raw Red Onion Menu items can be cooked to order. *Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

US$19.00

Veggie Burger

Topped with Mozzarella cheese and sauteed mushrooms served with Fries

US$17.00

American Cheese & Fried Onion Burger*

Menu items can be cooked to order. *Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

US$19.00

Home of the French Dip! - Burgers

Home of the French Dip! - Sandwiches & Wraps

Hot Pastrami On Rye

Hot pastrami with melted swiss on grilled seeded rye bread, served with french fries and a pickle.

US$17.00

Cajun Chicken Sandwich

Blackened Chicken Breast toped with Cajun Spices, melted Swiss Cheese and Fried Onions. Served with Horseradish Dressing on the side.

US$16.00

Rachel Reuben

Hot pastrami with melted Swiss, sauerkraut and Thousand Island on seeded rye bread, served with french fries and a pickle.

US$18.00

Turkey Club Wrap

Turkey, Crisp Bacon with Lettuce, Tomato and Mayonnaise.

US$16.00

Chicken Parm Hero

Fried chicken fingers topped with marinara sauce, mozzarella cheese on a fresh baked hero roll, served with Fries

US$16.00

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

Breaded chicken fingers in hot sauce lettuce and tomato served with Bleu cheese dressing.

US$16.00

Marinated Sliced Steak* Sandwich

Marinated sliced steak topped with melted Mozzarella cheese on garlic bread, served with two onion rings. *Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

US$25.00

Old Fashioned Turkey Club

Turkey layered with lettuce, tomato and bacon on toasted white bread.

US$17.00

Chicken Fingers BLT Wrap

Diced chicken fingers with bacon, lettuce, tomato, and American cheese on a hero, served with mayonnaise on the side.

US$16.00

Balsamic Chicken Sandwich

Grilled boneless chicken breast marinated in balsamic vinegar topped with Mozzarella cheese and diced tomatoes on a toasted roll.

US$16.00

BBQ Chicken With Bacon & Cheese

Boneless bbq chicken breast topped with melted Swiss cheese and crispy bacon on a toasted roll.

US$16.00

Garlic Roast Beef Melt

Boar’s head roast beef topped with brown gravy and melted Mozzarella cheese on a toasted garlic roll.

US$17.00

Hudson River Pastrami Hero

Pastrami, Sauerkraut, swiss cheese on a toasted hero served with thousand island dressing and spicy brown mustard

US$18.00

Fish Sandwich

Beer Battered Cod served on a fresh bakery roll and topped with American cheese

US$16.00

2 - Way Combo Fajitas (Chicken & Steak*)

Served over a bed of Grilled Peppers and Onions with Shredded Cheeses, Lettuce, Salsa and Sour Cream. Served with warm flour tortillas and rice. -add Guacamole 1.50 *Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

US$30.00

Chicken Fajitas

Served over a bed of Grilled Peppers and Onions with Shredded Cheses, Lettuce, Salsa and Sour Cream. Served with warm flour tortillas and rice. -add Guacamole 1.50

US$23.00

Steak* Fajitas

Served over a bed of Grilled Peppers and Onions with Shredded Cheeses, Lettuce, Salsa and Sour Cream. Served with warm flour tortillas and rice. -add Guacamole 1.50 *Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

US$28.00

Shrimp In A Basket

Fried shrimp served with fries and coleslaw.

US$18.00

Chicken Fingers Platter

Our signature chicken fingers served with fries and honey mustard dressing.

US$17.00

Marinated Sliced Steak* Sandwich

Marinated sliced steak topped with melted Mozzarella cheese on garlic bread, served with two onion rings. *Consuming raw or undercooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

US$28.00

Chicken Finger Melt

Chicken Fingers, melted Swiss cheese, crisp bacon, lettuce and tomato on a toasted fresh burger roll served with fries and honey mustard dressing.

US$17.00

Penne Ala Vodka

Penne tossed in our house made Vodka sauce

US$16.00

Smothered Chicken Cutlet

2 fried chicken cutlet topped with brown gravy mozzarella cheese and sauteed mushrooms and served with rice and broccoli

US$20.00

Home of the French Dip! - Old City Public House Favorites

Home of the French Dip! - Jumbo OCPH Salads

Chicken Taco Salad Grande

Diced chicken with black olives, diced tomatoes, black beans, shredded lettuce, mixed cheeses salsa, and sour cream.

US$16.00

Buffalo Chicken Salad

salad greens, chopped fried chicken tossed in hot buffalo sauce, bacon, hard boiled eggs, blended cheeses and tomato served with bleu cheese dressing.

US$17.00

Beef Taco Salad Grande

Seasoned beef with black olives, diced tomatoes, black beans, shredded lettuce, mixed cheeses salsa, and sour cream. Consuming raw or uncooked meats, fish, shellfish or fresh shell eggs may increase your risk of food-borne illness, especially if you have certain medical conditions.

US$16.00

Chopped Salad

A combination of iceberg and romaine lettuce topped with chopped tomato, cucumbers, roasted red peppers, raw onions, and shredded cheese, served with garlic bread. - Add Grilled Chicken 4 or Sliced Marinated Steak* 5

US$15.00

Chicken Ceasar Salad

Grilled chicken served over a bed of romaine lettuce tossed in Ceasar dressing

US$18.00

Cold Chicken Cutlet Salad

Iceberg lettuce topped with sliced mozzarella, roasted red peppers, diced tomato's and a homemade chicken cutlet served with balsamic vinaigrette design on the side.

US$17.00

Penne Ala Vodka With Grilled Chicken

Penne tossed in our homemade ala Vodka sauce and topped with Grilled chicken

US$17.00

Penne Ala Vodka With Chicken Parmigiana

Penne tossed in our home made ala vodka sauce and topped with Chicken Fingers Parmesan

US$18.00

Home of the French Dip! - Pasta